Wednesday 4 July 2012

The Wrong Boy by Suzy Zail

I've been trying to work out what I want to say about The Wrong Boy for a couple of days now.

The writing was pretty good, the story was exactly as you would expect from a teen romance/holocaust story and the history was accurate. But I was uncomfortable the whole time I was reading it.

I've read quite a lot of Holocaust literature over the years.

It is a subject I return to regularly, almost obsessively at times.

I am not Jewish or German, and I have not lived through a world war.

But ever since my first real brush with Nazi Germany in my Year 9 history class I have been on a mission to understand how the Holocaust could have happened.

My head, heart and soul are continually searching for the answers to how & why it is that 

Man's inhumanity to man
Makes countless thousands mourn!
(Robert Burn - Man was Made to Mourn: A Dirge - 1784)

And that's when I realised what was wrong about The Wrong Boy - it didn't provide me with any clues or insights into man's inhumanity to man. I was not provoked into confronting any of my preconceived ideas or challenged into see a new perspective.

Fictionalising the Holocaust is not an easy job.
Many Holocaust stories are actually based on real events and real people with the author often feeling compelled to write the story as a way of processing their own family history and bearing witness. This kind of writing can be cathartic for the writer and eye-opening for the reader.

Perhaps if I was still a teenager just beginning my quest to understand, The Wrong Boy may have provided me with some answers. But as an adult, it failed to bring anything new into the ever-expanding field of Holocaust literature.

Suzy Zail has also written books for adults including 'The Tattooed Flower' about her father's experiences during the Holocaust.

P.S. I felt compelled to check what the rest of you were saying about this book on your blogs, especially the teen/YA readers.

There were many rave reviews that declared they were moved by this story and that they were shocked by many of the descriptions of events that were new to them. They were recommending this book to friends and hoping it would win awards. There were lots of blog discussions on man's inhumanity to man.

Knowledge is indeed a powerful thing. The more people who know about the Holocaust and are appalled by it, the less chance we have of history repeating itself.

1 comment:

  1. Hi! Sorry you were disappointed with this book. I just popped over to pass this on to you:


This blog has now moved to Wordpress.
Please visit This Reading Life to comment.

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.