Sunday 23 August 2015

Gone With the Wind - Final Post

Phew! We made it.

After two months of all things Scarlett and Southern sentiment it is time to draw the curtains and dim the lights on the O'Hara's and the Confederacy.

Rereading Gone With the Wind after twenty+ years was an unexpected treat. I was worried that it may have dated or that I may have moved on in my literary tastes. I was delighted to discover that it was as fresh, rich and as engaging as the first read.

Yes, there are modern concerns about the depiction of slavery, women and the Confederacy. And Mitchell has infused the story with a strong sense of nostalgia. However these views reflect not only the period of time that Mitchell wrote about, but also the period of time that Mitchell herself grew up and lived in.

Our reading of GWTW is now influenced by the thoughts and beliefs of our period of time.
In the future, different understandings and sensibilities will have evolved again and our reviews will simply be a part of the timeline of this remarkable book.

I believe that this is what makes GWTW a classic.
Despite the constantly changing landscape that is its historical, social and cultural contexts, the underlying themes of friendship, strength, courage, belonging and morality have been and will be endlessly fascinating to readers across all times.

Corinne, early on in the Gone With The Wind readalong, mentioned that Margaret Mitchell was very interested in psychology and that the development of Scarlett's character reflected this interest.

From the start I was struck by Scarlett's distinctive behaviour and language which had lots in common with Borderline Personality Disorder. But as the story went on I realised that Scarlett didn't exhibit the usual BPD characteristics of unstable self, hostility and irresponsibility.

A quick google search found that Scarlett's character more accurately reflects Histrionic Personality Disorder (HPD).

A few of the typical HPD characteristics are:
  • Attention-seeking behaviour
  • "life of the party"
  • Initially lively, dramatic and charming
  • Use physical appearance to draw attention to themselves
  • Inappropriate sexually seductive or provocative behaviour
  • Rapidly shifting and/or shallow expression of emotions
  • Impressionistic speech style lacking in detail
  • Self-dramatisation, theatricality & exaggerated expression of emotion
  • Highly suggestible
  • Considers relationships to be more intimate than they actually are
  • Craves novelty, stimulation & excitement
  • Impulsiveness
  • Intolerant of, or frustrated by delayed gratification
  • "drama queen"
  • "victim" or "princess"
  • Manipulative
  • Unconcerned about how their actions harm or upset others
A common BPD/HPD saying.
Antisocial, Narcissistic, Borderline, and Histrionic Personality Disorders are all closely related since they all share the same core feature of antagonism.
This core feature is an exaggerated sense of self-importance, insensitivity towards the feelings and needs of others, and callous exploitation of others. These antagonistic behaviors put the individual at odds with other people. If an individual has one of these antagonistic personality disorders, they are very likely to have another. (

Initially I had planned to add quotes or descriptions that highlighted Scarlett's HPD traits. But there were so many that in the end it felt completely unnecessary to rehash the whole book to prove each point!

However my curiosity and interest in this side of Scarlett's personality gave me insights into why we love to hate her and hate to love her. 

Yes, she is strong, independent and very capable. She can also be sassy, smart and sexy. We can admire and even respect these traits. However her motivations, words and subsequent actions so often negated the good she actually did. 

Having experienced up close and personal the roller coaster ride of someone with BPD, I understand Rhett's "I don't give a damn" comment.
It is exhausting being around someone like this, especially an untreated, in denial someone like this.

The constant drama's lose their appeal very quickly and the emotional manipulations take their toll until you just can't do it any longer and you simply don't believe or trust they can ever change (despite all their promises to the contrary).

Which is why I firmly believe that Rhett and Scarlett will never get back together. Scarlett's future manipulations to get Rhett back will only reinforce to Rhett why he should keep his distance. Peace, charm and grace are not in Scarlett's repertoire.

In my opinion, the main feeling Rhett experiences as he walks out the door is one of pure relief (tinged with sadness and regret no doubt, but relief nonetheless).

Rhett is no angel, but he is fully cognizant of his own behaviours and motivations. He accepts responsibility for his actions and character flaws. At the end he simply realises that Scarlett's charm is best viewed from afar. The reality of living with it is no longer so delightful to him.

Mitchell's ending may not make every reader happy, but it reflects the usual (untreated) HPD/BPD relationship trajectory.

I found myself surprised by how much I thoroughly enjoyed this reading of GWTW though. Comments and reviews that have come my way over the years, had led me to believe that it wouldn't live up to my fond memories. And the BPD connection made for some uncomfortable reading at times.

If you haven't read GWTW yet, please reconsider. It's an epic read with fascinating characters, set during a remarkable period of American history. It's a Pulitzer Prize winning, American classic for very good reasons.

Interesting facts from Margaret Mitchell's real life that turned up in GWTW:
  • Grandfather Mitchell was a Confederate soldier who made a large fortune selling lumber in Atlanta during Reconstruction.
  • Her maternal grandfather emigrated from Ireland and eventually settled near Jonesboro on a plantation.
  • Her family lived on Peachtree Street.
  • In 1918 she became engaged to Clifford Henry who died shortly after in action in France.
  • The following year Mitchell arrived home from college the day after her mother's death of Spanish 'flu.
  • She was an "unscrupulous flirt" and found herself engaged to five men at once!
Curious facts about GWTW:
  • Scarlett was actually called Pansy O'Hara right up until publication.
  • Mitchell wrote the last chapter first.
My check-in post for chapters 21-30 is here.
Chapters 31-40 is here.
And chapters 51-60 is here.


  1. Anonymous24/8/15

    I cannot count how many times I have seen this movie. I know some parts 'verbatim'.
    In 2012 I bought the book and... it is still on the shelf.
    What is holding me back? Will the book surpass the magnetic appeal of the movie?
    Is that possible?
    Your review has pushed me closer to a read....Pulitzer? How can I resist now?
    Great insights....and trivia facts!

    1. YOU MUST READ IT! :)

    2. Anonymous24/8/15

      I promised you, Jillian, in 2012 I would read it....
      I'll start today.... :)
      ps still very happy I discovered your " Classics" blog....way back then!

  2. Marvelous review Brona. When I saw you doing the read-along, I was curious how this book would appeal outside the USA. I'm glad to hear it was poignant.

  3. xxx You had me at "Gone with the Wind - final post." Early reviews suggested Scarlett was a sociopath, which Margaret Mitchell found quite intriguing. :) Great thoughts on the histrionic personality!

  4. Anonymous25/8/15

    Thanks for all of your wonderful posts on GWTW; your thoughts on Scarlett really added to my reading experience as I would have never thought about her as being mentally ill. And you make a great point that readers' reactions to the book are a reflection of the time they are reading it in. I agree with you that it is a classic and that we should continue to consider it one. I am glad that the read-along gave me the push I needed to pick it up; it was a great read.

  5. Oh dear, I can't envision our heroine as "Pansy O'Hara". I really enjoyed reading your final thoughts on the book and agree that GWTW is worth the time it takes to read it. I'm still working on it!

  6. Yeah I havent read GWTW in 20 + years either. I'm glad to hear it still stands up as a great read. I'm also glad Scarlett's name in the book wasn't Pansy. Yikes!

  7. That was very interesting. I haven't read GWTW and I don't intend to as it was my m-i-ls favourite book and she read it often. I think she adored Scarlett and identified with her! Pansy just wouldn't have worked.

  8. Thank you a wonderful and interesting post on GWTW. This is my favourite book and I read it years ago. Maybe I should read it again, this time in English. Interesting about possible disorders of book heroines! She certainly was no ordinary gal!


This blog has now moved to Wordpress.
Please visit This Reading Life to comment.

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.